Home Blog Online Dating Safety

How to Build Trust Again After Being Hurt in a Past Relationship

If you’ve ever had your heart broken, your trust betrayed, or your loyalty met with lies, you know how hard it is to fully open up again. Even when you meet someone new — someone kind, consistent, and safe — that inner voice whispers: Don’t get too comfortable. Don’t get hurt again.

Rebuilding trust after being hurt isn’t about flipping a switch. It’s about learning to feel safe in your own skin again — and eventually, safe with someone else. That takes intention, healing, and time.

This guide will help you unpack how trust gets broken, how to rebuild it in yourself and others, and how to love again without losing your emotional boundaries.

Why Broken Trust Hurts So Deeply

Trust isn’t just about believing someone won’t cheat. It’s about emotional safety. It’s the deep, subconscious knowing that:

They’ll show up when you’re vulnerable.
They won’t use your honesty against you.
They’ll protect the connection — not just themselves.

When someone violates that — through betrayal, manipulation, ghosting, or lies — it fractures not only your view of them, but your trust in your own judgment. That’s why healing trust is so layered.

How Betrayal Changes the Way You Date

After being hurt, your nervous system adapts to stay “safe.” You may notice:

Constant overthinking and emotional scanning
Difficulty receiving affection or compliments
Avoidance of vulnerability
Mistrust of your own feelings (even when someone seems genuine)

According to trauma expert Dr. Bessel van der Kolk, author of The Body Keeps the Score, the mind rewires itself after relational trauma to avoid repeating the same pain — but this often leads to disconnection and loneliness.

Step 1: Rebuild Trust in Yourself First

Before you can trust others, you have to trust your own intuition, boundaries, and ability to protect your peace. Here’s how to start.

1. Reflect Without Blame

Instead of asking “Why did they do this to me?”, ask:

What were the red flags I ignored?
What did my body feel when I first sensed something was off?
Where did I silence myself to keep the peace?

This isn’t about blaming yourself — it’s about reclaiming your power.

2. Strengthen Your Boundaries

After betrayal, it’s common to swing between walls and overexposure. Find your center by practicing clear, kind boundaries.

For example:

“I need consistent communication to feel safe in a relationship.”
“I move slowly in dating because emotional safety is important to me.”

Boundaries aren’t rules for them — they’re reminders for you.

3. Forgive Yourself

Maybe you stayed too long. Believed too much. Ignored the signs. That doesn’t make you foolish — it makes you human.

Self-forgiveness is the first layer of healing trust. Without it, you’ll keep punishing yourself long after the other person is gone.

**Step 2: Learn What Trustworthy Behavior Looks Like**

People who are emotionally trustworthy tend to share these traits:

Consistency: Their words and actions match — over time.
Emotional availability: They don’t avoid vulnerability or conversations.
Accountability: They own mistakes without defensiveness.
Respect for your pace: They don’t rush intimacy or ignore your boundaries.

If someone constantly asks for your trust but never earns it through behavior, it’s a red flag — not a challenge.

Step 3: Take Things Slowly — And Let Them Prove It

You don’t need to force trust. You can build it over time — like a bridge, not a leap.

How to pace trust:

Observe how they handle conflict. Do they attack or stay grounded?
Watch their patterns. Do they show up, even when it’s inconvenient?
Check how they react to your boundaries. Do they honor or pressure?

As relationship coach Matthew Hussey says in this article, “Trust is earned through repeated moments of reliability.”Let them show you who they are — don’t just hope.

Step 4: Communicate Your Experience Without Shame

When you start to feel close to someone, share your past pain gently — not to test them, but to create understanding.

Try:

“I’ve been through some trust issues in the past, so I tend to move a little slower emotionally. I just wanted to be transparent with you.”

A trustworthy person won’t make you feel wrong for that. They’ll meet you with reassurance — not guilt.

Step 5: Learn to Regulate Anxiety Without Needing Constant Reassurance

It’s okay to feel nervous. But try to separate fear from facts.

Instead of texting “Are you mad at me?” after a delayed response, pause. Breathe. Ground yourself.

Ask:

What’s the actual evidence here?
Is this based on the present, or the past?
What would I tell a friend in this situation?

Attachment theory teaches us that anxious attachment often stems from fear of abandonment — not current behavior. Learning to self-soothe builds trust from the inside out.

Step 6: Embrace Imperfection — While Staying Grounded

Trust isn’t about finding a perfect partner. It’s about finding someone who:

Fails sometimes — and then repairs
Listens when you express concern
Doesn’t punish you for needing safety

All humans will disappoint each other. But a healthy partner works through it — not around it.

Step 7: Don’t Rush Forgiveness for the Past — or the Present

You don’t owe quick forgiveness to your ex — or to yourself. Healing isn’t linear, and it doesn’t come with deadlines.

But you do deserve to let go — for your own freedom.

Forgiveness isn’t saying “It was okay.” It’s saying, “It no longer controls me.”

Signs You’re Starting to Trust Again

You’ll know your heart is healing when:

You stop needing to “test” people’s love
You express boundaries calmly, not defensively
You feel safe — even without constant contact
You trust yourself to walk away if something feels wrong

That’s not weakness. That’s emotional strength.

What If You Get Hurt Again?

It’s possible. But now you have tools.

You’ll notice red flags sooner. You’ll speak up earlier. You’ll walk away faster. And most importantly — you’ll remember that someone else’s betrayal says everything about them, and nothing about your worth.

Love is always a risk. But so is guarding your heart so tightly that nothing gets in.